Failure Is a Decision: When Do You Decide You've Failed?
A few weeks ago, at a Female Founders event, someone asked a question that got me contemplating: when do you have to decide that you have failed? My answer: failure is a decision, and you get to choose when, and whether, to make it.
Most of us decide way too early. A bad month, one setback, the inner critic on a loud day, and we quietly step out and call it failure.

Failure Is a Decision That Comes After the Feeling
A feeling is what shows up when something goes wrong: the drop in your stomach, the heat in your face, the voice that says see, you are not good enough. The feeling is real, and it is loud. It does not get to rule on the verdict.
The verdict is a separate act. Deciding you have failed is a choice to stop, to close the door, to call the project over. Most high performers let the feeling make the decision for them, on the worst possible day, with the worst possible judge in charge.
Why Your Worst Day Is a Bad Judge
There is a name for that judge. The imposter phenomenon, first studied by Clance and Imes in 1978 in high-achieving women, and shown by later research to affect men too. The pattern is a gap between real, visible accomplishment and a private certainty that you are a fraud about to be exposed. On a good day you manage it. On a bad day it grabs the microphone and calls a setback proof.
Underneath the voice is a body. A nervous system on alert reads any setback as danger, and danger wants you to retreat. In that state, stopping feels like safety and quitting feels like relief. A decision made from there is threat talking.
Does Failing Really Teach You Anything?
We love to say failure is the best teacher. The research is less romantic. In 2019, Eskreis-Winkler and Fishbach published five experiments in Psychological Science showing that people learned less from their own failures than from their successes. The culprit was the sting: failure threatens the ego, attention turns to protecting yourself, and the lesson slides off. The same people learned perfectly well from watching other people fail, because their own ego was not on the line.
Failure only teaches once the threat is handled. A regulated body can look at what went wrong and take in the information. An overwhelmed one just wants the pain to stop. The motivational posters skip this part: you cannot learn from failure while your system is busy surviving it.
How to Decide From a Regulated Body
Start in the body, because the false verdict comes from there. Pick something you are bad at: a push-up, a pull-up, a handstand against the wall. Try it. Then watch two separate moments: when your body wants to quit, and when you decide to stop. They are two different moments. Most people call the first one failure. It is a wobble.
Then lower the stakes with play. Pick something you know you will fail at and fail at it on purpose, as a game. How badly can you fail? When you choose the failing, the sting has nowhere to land, and the ego steps out of the way so you can see what happened.
Audacity and self-compassion go together. You need the audacity to take up space and keep going, and the self-compassion to stay in the game when it gets messy. Both run better on a regulated nervous system than on a loud inner critic.
When do you have to decide you have failed? Later than your bad day wants you to. And only once your body is calm enough to make the call, instead of your inner critic making it for you.
If you want support staying in the game through the messy stretches and the hard decisions, let's talk



Comments